What Is Backup Withholding? A Comprehensive Guide to Tax Regulations

Basics

Backup withholding is a flat 24% federal tax that a payer holds back from certain payments when the recipient has not given a correct taxpayer identification number (TIN) or the IRS tells the payer to start.

Why it exists

The IRS uses backup withholding to make sure tax is collected on income that is otherwise hard to track, such as interest, dividends, and payments to independent contractors. The payer sends the withheld amount directly to the IRS.

When it applies

  • You did not give your TIN (Form W-9).
  • The IRS notified the payer that the TIN you gave is incorrect (a “B” notice).
  • The IRS notified the payer that you underreported interest or dividends (a “C” notice).
  • You failed to certify that you are not subject to backup withholding on a new interest or dividend account.

Payments covered

Interest, dividends, rents, royalties, nonemployee compensation, broker and barter exchange proceeds, and payments reported on Form 1099-K. It does not apply to regular wages, which have their own withholding, or to most payments made to corporations.

What is backup withholding: main illustration

The rate and an example

The rate is 24%, set in 2018 by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. For a $5,000 contractor payment, the payer would send $1,200 to the IRS and pay you $3,800.

How to stop it

Give the payer a correct, signed Form W-9. After a B notice, you generally have 30 days to provide a correct TIN. For a second notice within three years, you need a confirmation from the Social Security Administration or an IRS letter 147C. For a C notice, the IRS must release the withholding, and you can request it by following the notice instructions.

Backup withholding versus regular withholding

What is backup withholding: visual explanation
  • Regular withholding comes from wages and is based on Form W-4.
  • Backup withholding comes from non-wage payments and is a flat rate.
  • Both are credited to you on your tax return.

You get credit for it

The amount withheld is reported to you on the information return (box 4 of Form 1099) and to the IRS. You claim it as a payment on your tax return, so it is a prepayment, not an extra tax. If it exceeds your tax, you get it back as a refund.

Duties for payers

Payers must collect W-9 forms, withhold when required, deposit the money on schedule, and report it on Form 945. Failing to withhold can make the payer liable for the amount.

What is backup withholding: example and key details

Common mistakes

  • Writing the wrong name or number on the W-9.
  • Ignoring a B notice and missing the 30 day deadline.
  • Assuming it is a penalty, when it is a prepayment.

Based on data from the Internal Revenue Service (Topic 307, Publication 1281, and Form W-9 instructions).

Rate article